Summary: This game is a mixed bag of good and bad. Some things it did really well for a 2008 game, while other things either was not done well or was just lacking. The graphics are surprisingly very good with all kinds of details you wouldn't normally expect in a sports game. They even sweat at different levels based on their heart rate and get dirt and sweat marks on their clothes.
Summary: This is one of the worst. The response time is horrible, player movement and hitting the ball are pretty bad. I've played other tennis games before. This is just not playable to me. I can't get the freaking players to hit the ball when they are supposed to and move. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY!!!
Summary: I picked this one up because I was looking for a cheap tennis game on the xbox. While I would not say this game is bad, it is nothing spectacular. The graphics on it are pretty good, and you get a good amount of courts to play on, but some of them give you a real hard time seeing the ball when it is in play. The roster is pretty good, but for when it came out it is lacking a few big name players that would have added quite a bit to it.
Summary: Top Spin 3 may not be the latest game in the series, but it is certainly the best in my opinion. You can play exhibition singles or doubles matches with any player you want, including some all-time greats. But what you really want to play is the Career mode. You make your own character and start in an amateur league. Then make your way up the chain to Professional and play against real life players. One thing that kind of confused me was no Rafa Nadal.