Summary: This game is awesome. I highly recommend it to any RPG lover. There are something like six totally different endings to the main story depending on decisions you make, so there is a great value of replayability, and at the end of the first chapter, you need to make a major decision on which of two paths your going to take, which dictates which quests you will and will not do, and which places you will and will not visit for the rest of the game.
Summary: Good storyline. Great character development. Can be very challenging at points. Branching skill trees. Different endings. Good graphics. Very good music. This is a treat of a game. My only complaint is with the occasional QTE as I've never liked them. Thankfully they are few and far between. Definitely not suitable for children, btw.
Summary: This game has an interesting story, but the actual game mechanics are quite poor in my opinion. Moving feels awkward and I rarely feel immersed in the world. For example, having to get to a meeting point on a map I was unable to to go any way I liked. I couldn't swim, I couldn't, jump over small rocks, I couldn't go through the trees... I HAD to stick to the path! Of course, there were conveniently placed 'random' bandits waiting. Boring.