Excerpt: Après Halo Wars, End War ou bien encore Command and conquer 3, c'est au tour de Sega de venir nous présenter Stormrise , dernier né des STR sur console dont le genre a le vent en poupe comme nous vous le signalions dans la présentation. Il est clair que les bons STR sur console ne sont pas légion pour le moment, notamment en regard de la qualité de ceux sortant régulièrement sur PC.
Excerpt: I had never heard about Stormrise prior to when I was asked to write a review for it, not once having come across a preview, press release or even a batch of screenshots, so I knew next to nothing about the title when I first popped the disc in the drive.
Conclusion: Takes about 8-10 hours to boost all the online achievements. Then the campaign achievements are extremely boring and you got to beat the game twice. - 1/6 Good game? One of the worst game I have ever played in my entire life and right now the worst xbox game I have ever played - 0/6 Total points for Stormrise 3/24
Excerpt: Real-time strategy games have never really gotten along with home game consoles. Despite several valiant attempts at bringing RTSs to consoles, the task of directing dozens, if not hundreds, of on-screen units has always been more manageable with a mouse and keyboard than with a game controller. Recently, Halo Wars made some strides towards making the genre more compatible by stripping down the controls to fit better on an 8-button controller, as did EndWar with its...
Excerpt: The question of how to successfully port the RTS genre to home consoles is one that is – arguably – still unanswered. Creative Assembly are the latest team to step up to the plate and have a crack at it, with Stormrise’s success hinging on their new “Whip Select” system. The idea behind Whip Select is that with your right stick, you simply point in the direction of the unit that you want to control, and the camera “whips” to that unit, allowing you to issue orders and...
Excerpt: Communication is a vital tool, no matter the technology being modern or primeval. Without it, co-ordination becomes almost impossible and decisions are made instinctively based on gut feelings. In a military operation, this could lead to disaster and a huge loss of human life. Pity then that the people at Creative Assembly are a cold-hearted bunch. It’s never really clear what is happening in Stormrise or why you’re given such orders.
Conclusion: In light of the game's ambitiously advertised, but ultimately disastrous technology, one has to wonder just how many hours were actually spent on testing this shambles of a game. Whoever worked on this project should've been sent to do something more useful. Hm, like ironing out bugs in Empire: Total War ? Stormrise is a great example of how to mess up a great concept.
Pros: There is potential here... if you're persistent enough to look;
Cons: Extremely flawed controls, lousy pathfinding and AI, a game that never should've been let out the door, Creative Assembly's greatest flop.
Conclusion: It would have been better if The Creative Assembly had included some more casual “affirmative”s and “orders received”s in there, but it still wouldn’t be much better. In the future, let’s spend less money on voice actors saying unnecessary bullshit and more money on developing awesome pointing systems. OK?
Summary: Stormrise is a real-time strategy console title offering fans of the classic RTS genre an immersive and dramatic twist whilst challenging the conscience. Experience the heat of the battlefield by leading your troops from the front line, instead of the traditional way of controlling the units from a detached viewpoint.