Summary: Being a fisherman, i was excited to hear that there was an actual fishing game for kinect. I had thought about how cool it would be, making reeling motions, driving the boat, casting, etc. i had to pick it up. Though i couldn't find it in any stores or Gamestop i went ahead and rented it. And let me say, BIGGEST LET DOWN ever. The game gets a 4 from me because of horrible gameplay, dated graphics, cheesy music, and just an overall outdated feel to it.
Summary: I purchased this game as a birthday gift for my husband, whom loves fishing. I assumed you would actually use the hand movements and lean back to really "reel" the fish in. Not the case at all. The person on the screen shows you what hand motions or moves to make to get the fish. Not as realistic as I expected. My husband doesn't like it, doesn't play it at all. However, my 4 year old daughter LOVES it and plays it on a daily basis.