Summary: Wow! I AM surprised. I thought this was going to only be a mediocre little game with no replay value that would get boring within after only a few times of playing. Boy was I wrong. This game is wonderful. I was looking for fishing games to play on my new 360 and saw this. At the time it was the cheapest one out there, but I still had my qualms about it after seeing on gameplay vids that it looked very arcady -- to arcady for me.
Summary: This game is none stop button mashing. You do not fish by tapping multiple button is succession. This might be the worst fishing game i have ever played, this is the worst game i have ever played.
Summary: This game is a real tough one to evaluate. The graphics are awesome, and the fishing is varied enough to make it interesting. BUT... on certain lakes (which I cringe at when I see them loading) there are SO MANY GLITCHES that is makes it almost impossible to get through the level... or at least so frustrating that you'll just want to play something (anything) else.
Summary: I love to fish and have played several other fishing games on other platforms. This game is hard to learn and frustrating. Maybe it is just me, but there are too many things to try and do to keep the fish on the line and reeled in (I have yet to catch a fish and get it too the boat). I was looking for something that was more intuitive to play and actually catching a fish would be great!