Summary: Most of the problems that I have heard are about the lack of pre-game or post-game presentation or bulky players or how slow they move. I own the game and the other features more than make up for these small and trivial oversights. Legend mode is a fantastic addition to the 360 and almost makes the game worth $60 on its own.
Summary: I was first hooked on the NCAA franchise last year while waiting for Madden to be released. I especially enjoyed the Dyansty mode. I actually thought NCAA 07 was a better game than Madden 07, even though I am not into college football. This year I was definitely up for playing 08. After reading a review in EGM, I took the advice of the writers and decided to pick up the XBOX 360 version.
Summary: When I typed up the first review of this game I really didnt give the game a chance. This game is so different from any other EA football game. The animations are different and even though they look like they run a lot slower than the previous versions, it also runs a lot smoother. Sometimes slower is better. The graphics, as always, are top notch.
Summary: Ok I admit it, EA hasnt been making good soccer games lately, (you can see my rant on the product pages for FIFA 07 and UEFA) but I have always been impressed with the NCAA and MADDEN series coming out of EA Tiburon. Therefore you can be assured that if this game was a piece of junk, I would have said so already. Graphics: On the graphics side, you can easily tell the difference in the very first play of the game.