Summary: This game isn't half bad once it's patched. Decided to pick up it up since I saw it had better graphics then 2K10, and it isnt bad. The player faces are way crappier on this game, but the overall graphics are nicer. Errors happen way too frequently though, and are almost non existent in 2K10. Maybe 2k11 will give us what we're looking for.
Summary: I must state that I am not what I would consider an avid gamer. I have never left a review for a game but feel that I must warn people before they purchase this product. I do play frequently but I typically limit myself to sports games and only do 52 game seasons in baseball. Initially I was impressed by this game, I'm a fan of the menu format and the graphics are on par with other 360 sports games.
Summary: This game is best better than last year's game. It runs smoother, it looks better, and in the beginning at least it is simply better during the actual game. However, some issues still carry over, and some new things exist: 1) Hitting the ball against the wall can result in the fielder merging into the wall and getting stuck. This is only resolved by jogging all the way home and scoring. I mean, maybe you could have gotten a triple..
Summary: This game makes me want to sell my 360 and get a PS3 and The Show. I had last years The Show for PS2 and it was a fantastic game. This game is far from a horrible game....but it is absolutely no where near I expect a baseball game to be. I would rather play Ken Griffey Jr baseball for the N64 than this game to be honest.
Pros: Graphics looked decent to an extent. Interface in-game was rather simplistic and well done. Pitching and hitting was easy to do.
Cons: A massive amount of bugs in the gameplay. Outfielders getting lost at the wall or running absurdly slow at a pop fly and it falling in. Hitting seemed scripted...in other words, if you try to pull it down the line to left field, you might get two different outcomes of ball placement...not varied enough. The off the field interface was a bit confusing at first and took a day or so to get used to.
Summary: This game is really not as bad as everyone makes it out to be. Yes there are glitches, what game doesn't have them, and there are some things that are just odd. Some things I noticed: -Outfielding is difficult, you have to really control your movements and can't start and stop on a dime, weird, kind of like real life. once the player is in the dark circle, very little movement is needed.