Summary: Really interesting mechanics for pitching/hitting, but really buggy and sloppily put together. Baserunners will get stuck on basemen and get tagged out while running in place; announcers will repeat themselves multiple times in a short span. Soundtrack is amazing. Fielding in "my player" mode is frustrating as hell.
Summary: The actual mean of the user score is really unfair for this game. Yes, needs an Xbox controller to be played properly, but this cannot be considered a fault imho, since the control system is well made and responsive. At the All Star difficulty level it also offers a good challenge, and it has much game modes to play with as My Player or a full MLB season with Drafts, Trades and all the stuff you can ask to a good baseball game.
Summary: Your are a baseball fan? you can not watch MLB tv when you whant (because of your wife of course...she'd like to sleep at night!)? You MUST BE THE OWNER OF MLB 2K11!!! Sit down in your sofa, swintch your Xbox on and... Here we go GIANTS!!! To be ordered!!
Summary: The game its self is fine, they improved alot of the stupid glitches except one. The stupid game freezes all the time. The last two times I have played it frooze. It freezes before the game, when they show a replay and sometimes between innings.
Summary: It's just an OK game. I much preferred EA Sports when they had the MLB games, but since this is the only choice, it will have to do. I find that hitting is very difficult. It's hard to decipher what kind of pitch is coming.