Summary: I waited on the 360 up till black Friday. That said this game does not impress me. It feels really slow and clunky. Hit detection is also just okay at best. I would hate to compare it to Uncharted but as that is one of the only other cover based TPS games I'd say uncharted isn't just much better, it is a entirely different experience. Overall..grab it if it's cheap. The generic world, story, and characters just didn't speak to me.
Summary: I can (sort of) understand why this game was perceived as a revolution. However, the single-player campaign suffer's from offering a likable story and enduring atmosphere. Technically, this game has aged well. The game engine is in good shape, with solid graphics (even up to this date) and I have not encountered any errors, bugs, etc. What stands as a positive remark is it's gameplay. The I can (sort of) understand why this game was perceived as a revolution.
Summary: This is a very good Xbox 360 -> Pc port. The controls are very good, aiming with mouse is very fluent and visuals are very good. On game play side it's fun, the story is interesting and the gun play is awesome. The only big downside I see is that sometimes it can get a little repetitive. With that said, I personally think it's one of the best shooters out here on Pc.