Summary: Gothic 4 is an entertaining medieval fantasy RPG. The world graphics and indeed the animations are top notch except when it comes to characters having a conversation, this is probably where the game looks it's most amateur.
Summary: If this game didn't call itself a Gothic game, I would have liked it a lot more. I spent lots of hours playing gothic. The completely open world, the crafting, the story, the game play, the side quests...EVERYTHING about Gothic was literally phenomenal.
Summary: I had been waiting for something like this for a long time and I'm completely happy with my purchase. I don't see any reason for a second play through, which might be another factor to consider before purchasing. I actually have been playing this over Fallout: New Vegas.
Summary: This game is terrible. Maybe it's the Xbox version that sucks more than the PC verison, but it's just terrible. It's riddled with bugs (including glitched achievements that are unattainable and will never be fixed... a HUGE sore spot for a completionist like myself).