Summary: If anything saves Top Spin, it is the online play – only there does the game offer any lasting enjoyment. Still, the control and organization problems make Top Spin much less of a game than it could have (and should have) been. Tennis is already a niche sport, so most gamers will likely ignore Top Spin. However, buying it isn’t necessarily a bad choice, since even with its problems those who enjoy the sport may find some value in it simply for the online play.
Pros: Strong create-a-player mode, Anna Kournikova.
Cons: Shallow single player mode, lack of precision.
Conclusion: No matter if you are a tennis fan or not, Top Spin is a game which you simply must have in your collection, and it'll even go down well with people who aren't much of a tennis fan, but after you've played Top Spin you'll be counting the days to Wimbledon.
Conclusion: THE VERDICT: Sports games have always benefited from more powerful hardware, and Top Spin manages to extract a visually pleasing game out of Microsoft's box that also contains a solid gameplay system. The singleplayer career mode might be a bit of a breeze at times, but the multiplayer hijinks will have you coming back again and again. Though there is still room for improvement, this is a damn fine tennis game that is sure to keep you entertained.
Excerpt: “Top Spin” is the complete tennis experience. Define your tennis playing style, take risks, pull off world-class shots, and work the crowd to develop a unique image on the court. You can also train with a coach to master shots and playing surfaces and work your way up the online rankings to become the best in the world.
Excerpt: Tennis fans have long awaited for
this point in time; the arrival of digital tennis that can return the serve provided
by its opponent Virtua Tennis. Since Virtua Tennis last graced store shelves, tennis
games have come and gone; all of which failed miserably in comparison. That is until
now...Top Spin tennis is a breath of fresh air that not only donates good company to
Virtua Tennis, it wipes the floor with the ancient title.
Conclusion: The Verdict While Top Spin tennis is plagued by a few minor control and gameplay issues, it is still by far the best tennis game available so far on the XBox, and the closest anyone has come to re-creating the classic feel of Virtua Tennis. If you've got a few friends to play it against, or a few aussie top spin players on your Live friends list, you'll get a lot of enjoyment out of the Exhibition and Multiplayer modes.
Conclusion: As good as Top Spin looks and plays (offline), with more varied shotmaking ability than any tennis game previously, it seems to lack the lasting appeal of Sega's seminal Virtua series. EA quickly learned that to make a sports franchise into a classic series they needed to add fun, which is what they did with Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2003 (and improved on with 2004), and PAM Development need to do the same with Top Spin, which is a realistic and good looking tennis game, but...
Pros: Nice graphics and sound., Nice variation in shots., Feels "tennisy"., Anna Kournikova.
Cons: Not enough variety and too easy to master the solo game., The Live game suffers from several problems., No mixed doubles., NO naked Kournikova cheat., Awful loading times.
Excerpt: 70-tallsklassikeren Pong, som startet underholdningsmaskinen vi i dag kjenner som dataspillbransjen, var en ren tennisopplevelse. En ball, to racketer, sort/hvitt-grafikk. Et haikudikt skrevet med piksler, som en mer poetisk spillanmelder kanskje ville beskrevet det. Vi beskriver det heller som et spill med forhistorisk grafikk og svært begrenset holdbarhet.