www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Netgear GS105
7.4 out of 10

Netgear GS105

For a high-speed network on a small scale, nothing delivers like Read more

Great Deal: $39.99

Reviews and Problems with Netgear GS105

Showing 1-10 of 19
Overall 6
6.0

Be careful when choosing between NetGear products

Lindstrom Morten, Amazon
20 October 2014
  • Summary: The product works, but this "review" is meant as a heads-up and warning for anyone who looks to purchase NetGear products. NetGears website have a lot of marketing info about their Plus Switch series, and lists up and down all the features that series have. But it is not very clear which features the different sub models have.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Good basic switch - Watch the features though

Ashton Clemens "Mr. Clemens", Amazon
7 August 2014
  • Summary: The phrase cutting corners comes to mind when reviewing this product. A few good reasons why are listed below. I realize that the device is technically labeled as "unmanaged" but to have a management interface and leave it like this is disappointing because the physical size is just right for where I needed to place this unit. 1.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Good switch - bad interface

David Howe, Amazon
22 May 2014
  • Summary: The switch hardware works well. The management interface program is a custom windows application and not a web or ssh interface. This is very troublesome as the protocol is blocked or shutdown by some antivirus apps. This product could be better with a web interface.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Not bad

jacobo m., Newegg
8 April 2014
  • Summary: I would go with another option, but this was the cheapest
  • Pros: Can't complain.
  • Cons: Used to have the same model but DIED after 4 month of use. Garbage equipment
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

The bottom Line.

Ryan, Amazon
25 December 2013
  • Summary: I'm a network engineer, and these little devices are pretty robust. I have noticed that they will drop individual packets every now and again. Nothing to extreme. I broke out wireshark, and started sniffing packets that flowed through this box, and looking at the technical specs, it appears that netgear did not include enough internal storage space to hold a NAT table larger them two to three devices.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Netgear GS105NA

DENNIS L., Newegg
29 December 2012
  • Pros: Works well.
  • Cons: Connecter housing is a bit lose. The connector it self is tight and secures the cable well but the rattle like housing leaves one unsure if it is a good connection or not.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Great features, slow and insecure management

Aaron S., Newegg
20 March 2012
  • Summary: Netgear has produced some really great hardware here, and made a serious effort to ruin it with poorly tested and incredibly vulnerable software. I don't hesitate to recommend this switch for an end-user in a very controlled environment, but I would absolutely recommend against using it in an environment where you might expect anyone to ever listen in to your traffic.
  • Pros: This switch does everything I could ask of it: VLANs, port mirroring, cable testing, QoS, and 802.1q support. It's also well-built, in a sturdy metal case, and looks like it will last forever.
  • Cons: The management interface is horribly convoluted. It uses a proprietary Adobe AIR application, requires that your PC be on the same subnet as the switch, but also literally broadcasts UDP to the FF:FF:FF:FF:FF:FF address, making sure everyone on your network gets your configuration, including your plaintext password. Netgear has seriously gone out of their way to invent a protocol and an application far more inconvenient and insecure than a simple web interface. Althou...
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Good with serious flaws

Riley F., Newegg
30 March 2010
  • Summary: This could be a very good switch once Netgear resolves the issues. I very much like the GS105 (non-e) switches and this is exactly the same plus the management features. Also, what's with the management interface? My alarm clock has web management, but I need an app to manage my switch?
  • Pros: Low cost Looks good! Small, efficient VLANs, QoS, Port Mirroring Lifetime Warranty!
  • Cons: Couple of things: The first being that this switch has a MAJOR bug in the firmware that causes it to respond to ANY pings. For example, if I ping a "fake" address like 12.34.56.78 the switch replies. If I ping a real address like 8.8.8.8 I get two replies. One from the switch and another from 8.8.8.8 with the second reply marked as DUP (Duplicate). Traffic sometimes stop flowing, assuming as a result of this issue. The netgear forums have some posts about this issue. ...
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

valt regelmatig uit !!

Peter Floren, routercenter.nl
1 May 2014
Overall 6
6.0

Empfindlich gegen Erschütterungen!

Detlef Moller, Amazon
15 March 2014
  • Summary: Ein schweres und solide verarbeitetes Produkt, das einen wertigen Eindruck macht. Im täglichen Einsatz überzeugt es besonders, wenn es irgendwo fest verschraubt und gegen Staub geschützt seinen Dienst verrichten kann. Liegt es offen herum, verliert es schon bei kleinen Erschütterungen oder beim Verschieben die Verbindung und muß neu gestartet werden. Dies ist bereits der zweite Adapter. Der erste hatte das gleiche Problem.
  • Read full review Translate to English
Next page >>