Summary: I was worried about the Icon freezer and refrigerator because there are so many inconsistent reviews online, but after a slight glitch with a separator panel keeping the freezer seal open a tad, thereby causing frost buildup, it now works great. The repairman came and took the panel out (it was only cosmetic) and no more frost! The contractor did have a devil of a time installing the two units with the trim kit, however.
Summary: I have the all fridge all freezer with the double louvered kit. The kit rattles every time the motor comes on loudly. The freezer size is fantastic but the fridge is quite a bit smaller than you would think because it is so short in height. The width is nice but you loose your standard interior space in the fridge. If you have any taller items, like juice or creamer, that you are unable to fit in the door, you will not be able to fit them in the fridge.
Summary: This all-refridgerator is very useful. You don't have to share it with a freezer. Big 25" platters fit for entertaining. The side door is great for gallon containers. Best product I've have ever bought. Wish I could fit the freezer mate that can be bought but didn't have the room in my kitchen...Bought the freezer and put it in my garage.