Summary: I have been playing EA's NCAA Football for years and have generally enjoyed it more than Madden. Now that I have young children, I find myself playing most of my games on the PSP rather than with an XBOX or PS - just to hard to find TV time. Thus, I have not played the other versions of NCAA 2010 so I just will be commenting on the quality of the gameplay for the PSP.
Summary: I completely agree with everything else everyone is saying. This game is very "dumbed down" while I understand it has to be to fit onto a psp screen, I think it's been down a little bit too much. With that being said, It is a good game for what I paid for it. it is football pure and simple. The problem that i have with it is you have to tweak it to get it to the settings.
Summary: See the psp gamer review for a pretty good and complete review for this game. I agree with pretty much all that's said from him however, I just wanted to add one more little detail. The "road to glory" can be very upsetting to the point where I just want to pull my hair out! It's a mode to where you create your player and try to get on the team you want. Once you're on a team depending on your position you may play in more plays than not.