Summary: I rented this from Gamefly and spent a couple weeks with it. I didn't even bother with the normal gameplay of single and season games, as I had no interest in that feature. The "Career" mode in MLB The Show has me spoiled for normal gameplay and I just cannot get into playing every single player on the field. What I did find interesting and engaging was the GM and managerial modes in this game.
Summary: If you played this game last year, this one is the same except with new rosters and a new cover athlete. 2K didn't do anything to improve this game from last year, it's just as crappy. The graphics are a step below 'The Show' but the presentation is actually decent. Some of the replays are nice to look at, but all these things can't hide the crappy gameplay.