Summary: Most people point to the rosters being old for when the game was released, and they are right, but that is a formality. The biggest problem is on kick returns, and being on offense when within your own 10.
Summary: I have had more enjoyment playing Blood Bowl than this game and that's a turn-based football crap game. Madden 12, in every way, sucks. I hate the menu for its stupid simplicity, there's no real animations and I don't feel the pump of winning a game like I do on the regular consoles.
Summary: My son could not wait to receive this and has not put this down since he got it. If he was allowed I am sure he would sleep with the game under his pillow :) A must get for any football enthusiast