www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Brother-hl-5170dn.32734071
6.5 out of 10

Brother HL-5170DN

Best Price at Amazon

Reviews and Problems with Brother HL-5170DN

Showing 1-10 of 40
Overall 10
10

Love this printer

Bookworm2, Amazon
27 March 2014
  • Summary: I know it's time to get another printer, a newer one, but this is a workhorse that I like so much that when my first one died, and I couldn't find this same model, new, I bought a used one. Glad I did. It's fast, does the job of making nice copies and is very dependable. Don't know why Brother stopped manufacturing them as opposed to upgrading them. Still, I applaud the fact that they created drives that allow me to use the Brother HL-5170DN with Windows 8.
  • Read full review
Overall 10
10

This has been an absolute workhorse for our organization

Scott D. Walters, Amazon
9 October 2013
  • Summary: We used up the toner that came with it, replaced that, and then mowed through most of that to the tune of hundreds of thousands of pages. Our non-profit prints sign up sheets, count sheets for field volunteers, petitions, fliers, and other things on this. It's been a workhorse. We're adding a color Brother laser printer. One huge selling point that's under advertised is PostScript emulation.
  • Read full review
Overall 8
8.0

Excellent Printer

J. Myles, Amazon
25 August 2011
  • Summary: I purchased the Brother HL-5170DN Laser Printer on sale for a very very good price. It worked exceptionally well for a long time. Then it developed problems. The USB port stopped working. I called tech support and they had no solution to the USB port problem, but suggested that I use the Paralell port. WOW, I though, let't go back in history. But that got the printer back in service for a while. THEN the paper started jamming.
  • Read full review
Overall 2
2.0

SirJamALot

Douglas Lyon "docjava", Amazon
15 October 2008
  • Summary: This printer jams all the time. Tech support advised using 24 lb paper, and this worked! So: Tech support knows about the jam. They know the problem can be fixed with heaver paper...but why won't they provide a fix that works with 20lb paper? If you want to print with normal paper, try another printer.
  • Read full review
Overall 10
10

Great Printer for the Dough

W. Quimby "Mac Geeeek", Amazon
17 August 2007
  • Summary: I'm a computer consultant specializing in the Mac platform. Two different clients of mine already had this printer for over a year and both were happy with it. I must say that it works nicely with both Macs and Windows PCs. Just load the drivers from the CD and go. Very nice print speed and quality. The duplexing and toner saver is excellent for saving resources. I also like the clever manual feed tray for checks and envelopes.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

I'm 50:50 pleased.

Deborah K. Hicks "Teacher creature", Amazon
14 August 2007
  • Summary: The machine is fast. The two flaws are: 1. the paper jams and curls frequently 2. the ink is not as bold as the inkjet. I bought the printer for faster and cheaper printing (use a lot of inkjet cartridges) since I do my own printing for classwork (school teacher).
  • Read full review
Overall 8
8.0

Crashes Computers in Network mode. Duplex is slow

Scott Roberts, Amazon
11 August 2007
  • Summary: I can only use it as a PC printer because it crashes my windows 98 PC if i try to print when it's connected to the router. Duplex printing takes longer than printing on one side and then fliping the paper over for the next side. Otherwise, it seems to work well. The best thing about it is that i can get toner from[...] for $20 a refill instead of spending $60 on the cartridge. I've used the same cartridge and drum with about 10 refills so far.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

No duplex for Mac, tough network setup for Windows XP

Cosmo_dog, Amazon
7 August 2007
  • Summary: Overall, I'm pretty happy with the Brother HL-5170DN, which I have set up in my home network of Macs and Windows computers. Print quality is crisp and it's plenty fast for a home network environment. I had to ding the printer for two reasons. The D and the N in the part number tout the two big features in this printer, namely duplex printing, and networking. This printer won't support duplex printing on Macs, and my network setup for Windows wasn't a smooth ride.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Printer won't mix and match legal and letter

WKRP, Amazon
21 July 2007
  • Summary: My review is limited to print capabilities: I bought the 5170 and the extra tray for the sole purpose of printing mortgage documents which alternate between legal and letter paper. This machine will not perform this function automatically. I write this review because I wish I had known this. I know other printer's exist which will perform this function. Live and learn.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

A little disappointing

Seacidal "Seacidal", Amazon
29 June 2007
  • Summary: After being very pleased with my Brother MFC-8220 laser fax/printer , I bought the Brother HL-5170DN for my office. I'm somewhat disappointed in that the printer has ocassional trouble handling envelopes. It will frequently jam. Also, while it installs smoothly and easily into Windows XP, and works conveniently with the controls in MS Word (2003), it is awkward to set printer paper controls from within WorkPerfect 11.
  • Read full review
Next page >>