www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Mlb-2005.292421
6.6 out of 10

MLB 2005

Great Deal: $16.95

Reviews and Problems with MLB 2005

Showing 1-10 of 53
Overall 8
8.0

Great Game

Michael P. Wood "Bobby Joe", Amazon
12 May 2007
  • Summary: Nice game to play, best yet the announcers are great. But one con is... You can't practice your swings before the picther throws the ball Overall I give this MLB 2005 a B+ Rating I also love the homerun derby, takes practice swinging though...
  • Read full review
Overall 8
8.0

Very Good Baseball Game

Amazon
11 April 2005
  • Summary: This game was very good because it has a lot of cool things to do. You can make up your own season and make lots of trades. There is also an option to just play an exhibition game. There are a lot of stadiums to pick from and a lot of real and fake teams to pick from.
  • Read full review
Overall 10
10

YOU BETTER BUY IT!

Carlos James, Amazon
5 March 2005
  • Summary: This is the best baseball game on earth. It is even better than EA sport's MVP 2005. My friend has that game, and I tried it. That game stinked. It had bad graphics. It wasn't even realistic like MLB 2005. So instead of MVP 2005, buy MLB 2005. The reason is IT'S A BETTER GAME!
  • Read full review
Overall 8
8.0

A Review

Ben "Greenday09", Amazon
11 December 2004
  • Summary: Overall this game is an O.K. game. It's not the best. Here are some pros and cons. Pros - Graphics are very nice. Franchise and career modes are very fun. If you're like me and you don't want to play the whole season, you can just simulate it. Unlockable features can help your team very much. You can even unlock old jerseys. Cons - It is almost impossible for the computer players to make an error. There is no Create-A-Team.
  • Read full review
Overall 8
8.0

Cool Game

Amazon
13 November 2004
  • Summary: I only gave it 4 stars because some of the calls aren't too good and plus they are somewhat strange... Being a ten year old, I think it should be better in graphics and you should not have to unlock allstar teams. Otherwise, I think it is a good game!
  • Read full review
Overall 2
2.0

NO BONDS !!! NO TAGGING RUNNERS Etc.

I. Lopez "Igyx", Amazon
29 October 2004
  • Summary: Unfortunately, this game is critically flawed. Basic baseball things can't be done. No check swings or wild pitches. I had a game in 1992 call Hardball II that could do these things. And it was on a single floppy. Can't tag a runner on a base line. If you want to switch positions of players while in the game... something that is done often in the real MLB to accomadate a change, is not possible. These are basic baseball realities that any descent game should have.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Question

Nathan L. Merritt "Crazzy_Man", Amazon
10 October 2004
  • Summary: I havnt bought this game yet. But once a question is answered I'll probably buy it. For the SF Giants (my favorite team), is there Jason Schmit and Brett Tomko? Email the answer to: nathanmerritt66@yahoo.com. Thanks!
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Not really great, but should have good/bad things

James Kim "yankeefan", Amazon
28 September 2004
  • Summary: This game is just like watching comic book with bad humor. Pros: Clear. Sharp graphics (All Star was like dullest) Great Songs Great Broadcast views Nice Frachise mode so was career mode Easy to dive and catch the ball. (I must have got 9 balls in a week) Difficulty was easy and good for beginner(I won 23-0 in my first game) New interactive hot/cold zones You get stuck to game like 3hours of playing game Good sound effects Nice replays Good Onlines Cons: Unrealistic...
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Good game, but some major flaws

M. Prentice "Splaktar", Amazon
24 September 2004
  • Summary: Overall the game is very fun. Many of the other reviews touch on some important pros and cons (no Barry Bonds, no Kevin Millar, lack of passed balls or wild pitches, etc). There's actually quite a lot more missing from the game. I don't see how any baseball game could ever be released without check swings! They are so critical to baseball! Can you imagine if the majors called every twitch or check swing a strike? It's ludicris!!!
  • Read full review
Overall 2
2.0

Ouch!

Adam D. Dunn, Amazon
24 August 2004
  • Summary: Why don't these companies give the game to even one fan before they release the game? The manual for this game is non existant so you have to guess how to play. Apparently there are "fantasy" players like Babe Ruth, I have no idea how to unlock them. Ok, 5 man pitching roster sucks. You have to warm up your bullpen but it takes a whole inning and you can't stall like in real life. You can't put in new players.
  • Read full review
Next page >>