www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Silent-hill-collection-415173.34140254
7.4 out of 10

Silent Hill HD Collection

Great Deal: $21.89

Reviews and Problems with Silent Hill HD Collection

Showing 1-9 of 9
Overall 4
4.0
Gameplay 5
5.0
Graphics 6
6.0
Sound 5
5.0
Lastability 4
4.0

Needs some more work to actually be a collection

Snowlex , GameStop
1 November 2013
  • Summary: Silent Hill 2 and 3 were the greatest games of the series. So what did Tomm Hulett, associate producer for Konami do with them? He put them in a collection, of course. But what exactly is missing here? Well, they're both beta game versions since Konami lost the originals, and are plagued with bugs. Silent Hill 1 and 4 are absent as well. Even if people didn't like Silent Hill 4 that much, you would still need to include it in the collection be complete.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0
Gameplay 6
6.0
Graphics 8
8.0
Sound 4
4.0
Lastability 5
5.0

A Classic...Ruined

SerialChiller , GameStop
28 March 2012
  • Summary: I've been a fan of Silent Hill since the first game on PS1 and like most other fans, I was a little nervous when I found out the rights were being sold to Konami America but I tried keeping an open mind. Downpour has been the best attempt so far though there were some technical issues that prevented it from being a 10. When I heard about the HD of 2&3 coming out, I was excited cuz those are the best in my opinion...however, after playing it...I'm VERY disappointed.
  • Read full review
Overall 3
3.0
Gameplay 5
5.0
Graphics 7
7.0
Sound 6
6.0
Lastability 3
3.0

Poor Ports

CatCouch , GameStop
27 March 2012
  • Summary: To start off I would like to say that Silent Hill 2 is my favorite game, so it saddens me to see how poor this collection presents these classics. I have played and beaten both games in this HD collection and encountered numerous issues. They both have lip syncing issues in pretty much every cutscene and both games stutter and slow down constantly.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

These games deserved far better treatment than this.

andy1989, Play.com
20 May 2012
  • Conclusion: Having read numerous reviews of this game collection online I will give my two cents worth... Firstly I have had the game a few days and have completed both titles.The first thing that springs to mind is the obvious probelm with the word"collection".A collection in game terms usually means a number of games or even trilogies like Prince of Persia or Jak and Daxter for example.Here we have merely Silent Hill 2 and three so I think this is false advertising from the get...
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

not as bad as I thought but still bad.

Samantha O'Connell, amazon.co.uk
15 May 2012
  • Summary: I had read reviews on how bad the game was in terms of graphics and the port job. Don't get me wrong like most other people who have reviewed and played on these games before it's a brilliant horror game. I used to play on it time and time again on PS2. But after I read reviews I decided to give it a go as it couldn't be as bad as people were saying right? Wrong.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

Depends on what you're prepared to live with

Mr. J. Hill, amazon.co.uk
22 April 2012
  • Summary: It's playable but has several small problems: 1. Frame rate shifts between 30fps and 60fps 2. Gameplay stutters a lot (you'll notice this when running around town) 3. Fog is different from how it was in the original. Hard to describe but everything seems to pop in at a very exact distance, wheras in the original it was more like real fog...? Something like that anyway!
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

That'll do...

M. Riches "_pantalaimon_", amazon.co.uk
14 April 2012
  • Summary: It's a shame i can't put as much effort into this review as the people who worked on the HD remastering of this collection. If i could it would be two words long... That'll do. Don't get me wrong, i can play games with minor issue with no problem, i have played games where people have been complaining on the internet and i've played the game and have barely even noticed them, or they were so minor they didn't effect my enjoyment of the game.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

What a shame

Phill, amazon.co.uk
3 April 2012
  • Summary: This is a real shame. I loved playing SH2 on the PS2 (SH3 less so - I'm not bothered about that too much). What has happened here is nothing short of a tradgedy and Konami should be ashamed to have their name on this title. Lets start at the beginning; the fog. What on earth happened to the fog effect? This looks like it's been done an an ancient Pentium 3 computer with a rubbish 16mb graphics card!
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

Gabriel Díaz, fnac.es
31 March 2012
  • Summary: Esperaba una remasterización digna. Konami ha destrozado la saga. No sólo no incluyendo Silent Hill 4 y 1 en el pack. Sino empeorando los otros dos. Han quitado la niebla (elemento clave de Silent Hill), empeorado la calidad del agua, "asfaltado" calles, redoblado y mal ambos juegos... etc. Podéis ver cualquier video en youtube que lo demuestra. Una chapuza.
  • Read full review Translate to English