Pros: Excellent game, were it not for the freezing and many, many glitches.
Cons: Freezes every 5 minutes, requiring a restart of the system, (only on Ps3 ) Many glitches including clipping issues, NPCs and player floating in mid-air, rare audio cut-outs, no patches to fix these things, no possible fix. AVOID PS3 VERSION. GET XBOX .
Summary: this game is awsome its a very fun game but the ending sucks pretty bad the ending blew me away i was suprised that it happend i would give this game a perfect 10 for everything but because of the ending i give it overall rating of 4 because i hated the ending im not going to tell the ending play the game and find out why the ending SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Summary: This game is very disappointing. The script does not follow the language or attitudes of 1911. You will find that John Marston uses modern day slang and often complains that skinning animals to be smelly and generally disgusting. The game play can be quite buggy from time to time as well. You will usually find it difficult to turn around, take shots or distinguish between friend and foe. This is further complicated by the auto-aim that does not discriminate.
Summary: This game in my opinion is repetetive, and after a while it gets boring, the blood and gore is amazing, the new creatures and weapons are fun, but this game is not a play again game this game to me is a game to play every then and again to mix things up, the story is intresting but you run all over the map doing so many things that do not add up to the story in my opinion. so I would recommend the game as being fun, but not for the price of 20+ dollars.
Summary: the graphics in this game are great the sound is great but the gameplay itself horrible!!! I mean it was just boring to me. But of course this is just my opinion, obviously many people like the game I don't. It just wasn't fun to me maybe you'll like it if you play it but I didn't I guess because I love playing extremely fast paced no stopping me kind of games this game has those moments but in between missions you kind of just wander around doing nothing
Cons: PS3 Good potential, but it has been unplayable. Video freezes during cut scenes. Video tearing and flickering. Older PS3s and the newer slim models. See: http://boardsus.playstation.com/t5/Red-Dead-Series/Red-Dead-Redemption-freezing/td-p/45671335
Summary: Hi! The game is ok.. but i dont like it because the online gaming mode (the most important for me!) is too dam hard... You start playing the game and u get always killed with headshots... its really boring... after a while u get really tired of it... I have read about this and it seems that if u train a lot with ur PS3 controller you will be able to perform a headshot kill by moving the analog botton a litle bit up before shooting...