Summary: The graphics keep getting better, and there are cool new features added every year, but in my opinion the gameplay has continually gone downhill. Unfortunately that is what I believe matters the most. I'd rather have bad graphics and fantastic gameplay any day of the week.
Summary: Last year's NCAA was one of the best football games ever made. In trying to improve the game this year, they took one step foward, two steps back. The brilliance of last year's game was the Locomotion engine, which made animations look more natural while giving the players a sense of weight and momentum.