Summary: I'm simply amazed. I had hoped that from peer reviews of PS3 football games that perhaps things had been fixed and it was finally time to buy a football game for it instead of my Xbox 360. The graphics are a step backwards alone then there is the gameplay. Defense AI is absolutely abysmal.
Line up the quarters for an arcade-style experience
Mike in C-Bus, Amazon
6 October 2008
Summary: Relative to previous versions of NCAA Football, this game is a non-challenging, dumbed-down shell of a football simulator that looks really pretty. EA Sports' long-time slogan "If it's in the game, it's in the game" used to mean something when it came to it's college football franchise.
Summary: This could have been a great game, had EA bothered to put it through QC testing. The graphics are very, very nice looking. However, this years edition has more bugs than ever, and that's saying something. Major things are broken. Tacklers should actually try to tackle the ball carrier, right?
Summary: I love the NCAA Football series. I've long preferred it to Madden. I love the atmosphere, the game to game pressure to win, the option offenses, all that. That's why this version of the game is such a monumental disappointment.