Reviews and Problems with Major League Baseball 2K12
Showing 1-10 of 13
2 September 2013
Summary: George Carlin said baseball was known as America's national pastime because "it takes so damn long to play a game." He was right. Never is this more clear than in playing simulated baseball in a videogame. While it does often retain the fun and excitement of being at the ballpark, it can also unintentionally include the tedium as well. Guess what MLB 2K12 includes?
Excerpt: Power pitchers are sexy again. Three years into its revamped look -- the dramatic reduction of offense, thanks to the elimination of steroid-fueled muscle men lugging bats to home plate -- a dominating hurler is more important than ever in Major League Baseball. These days, teams will sacrifice anything to get the likes of a flamethrower like Neftali Feliz or Justin Verlander to stand on their mound.
Pros: Great pitching mechanics, Impactful stats galore, Best sports game commentary
Cons: Choppy framerate at times, Dated, ordinary visuals, Feels phoned in
Excerpt: In baseball, as in all team sports, there are players who possess a particular skill useful in very specific situations. These players don’t have the ability to fill a team’s everyday needs, being used only when the occasion calls for them. These “specialists” are known as role players. The same could be said of Visual Concepts’ MLB 2K series. MLB 2K12 does few things well. But those few things are done very well.
Pros: Great broadcaster commentary, Brilliant use of player statistics, Solid pitcher-batter play
Excerpt: Spring has sprung early this year with summer-like temperatures, budding trees, and of course the start of spring training. That also means that the annual baseball franchises are back to the mound pitching their products to consumers. It's Major League Baseball 2K12 vs. MLB 12: The Show. Does MLB 2K12 hit a grand slam or strike out against its main competitor?
Conclusion: It almost feels like a patched version of 2K11 . With another challenger looming in the wings for next year's baseball crown it's likely that 2K will have to step their game up. Note to devs: please fix the shoes next year, too. I beg of you.
Excerpt: Since it's been a while for me, I wasn't used to the pitching mechanics of the 2K series. I think they are pretty clever. It works like this: pick your pitch, choose your placement with the left analog stick, then make a prescribed, two-part motion with the right stick. The first motion controls the speed as the reticule fills up. The second controls the movement. For a fastball it's pretty basic, pull back then push straightforward.
Summary: When it comes to baseball games, your choices are limited.
Pros: + Gesture-based pitching as rewarding as ever, impressive commentary when it works., +/- Online play doesn’t lag where it counts, but staggers everywhere else.
Cons: + Gesture-based pitching as rewarding as ever, impressive commentary when it works., +/- Online play doesn’t lag where it counts, but staggers everywhere else., - Emotionless players, frustrating fielding, mistimed commentary.
Excerpt: Being the understudy to a beloved star is a tough job. Your efforts seem all the more disappointing because people compare you to another, more popular performer. This also applies to 2K's baseball games; whatever they do, year after year, they just can't escape an unfavorable comparison to Sony's superior series, MLB 12: The Show . MLB 2K12 tries to stand out with an easy to grasp analog pitching system.
Pros: Right analog pitching works well, Solid commentary
Cons: Very few improvements over last year, Numerous graphical glitches, Poor fielding transition animations, Questionable AI decisions
Excerpt: Every year, sports fans ask the same question when a new franchise entry arrives: “How is it different from last year’s title?” Sometimes, the differences are significant and appreciated, and the series takes another positive step in the right direction. Other times, the progression isn’t as pronounced, making it hard for critics to recommend another $60 purchase.