Summary: Negatives- No more having your face on a body with eyetoy. Not as much selection in people. Judges most aways give you positive comments so not as funny or true. Cost more then old and better idols first one was the best. Pros- Can do makeup and stuff, Better songs and more song's I would not buy it again that's my opinion. I would get the first American Idol or the 1st Encore. Then you can personalize yourself. Also you get funny comments.