Summary: Ok expansion, Vanilla 10 BC 8 Wrath 7 Cata 6 Panda 4 . Even if wrath had atmosphere, the lich king fight was amazing, this expansion was the beginning of casual play. they had dumb down every raid to let even the dumbest raiders to be able to do a given raid !!!
Summary: This was the last good WoW expansion, that finishes up the story going on since Warcraft III. The expansion started great, but as it went on, too many good things in the game where nerfed or taken out. From the Trial of the Crusader patch on the game started feeling to easy, and not as much fun.
Summary: Teen son loved it. Reads through it now and again. Entertaining on long trips when he's in WOW withdrawal. Authentic - keeping the virtual world alive on page. Like methadone, I guess, when the heroin is not available.
Summary: it's all for the Death Knights the bad asses of Azeroth, once you start playing them, especially post patch 5.2(now 5.4) you'll understand why being anything but subtle killing machine is a good thing whether your horde or alliance
Summary: Wrath of the Lich King was a slight dissapointment for me. The questing and dungeons seemed to be tuned to be way too easy. Some things were improved, 5 mans and raids no longer had an hour's worth of trash that you had to go through to get to the bosses, they just had a couple of groups of minions...