Summary: Really annoyed that I'd have to ship the empty box with a single code back to get my money. Not worth it. Do not buy.
Cons: I had to wait for them to ship me an empty CD case of the game, with just a code to download Barnacle bay (I expected that). The code on the inside of the box however, expired March 31, 2012. I feel like I got ripped off. I can't return the product because it's a disc. BUYER BEWARE. CODE IS EXPIRED.
Summary: Barnacle Bay adds nauticle items to your game. It doesn't inhance or deflect from the fun of the game, just adds a little flavor. If you're hard core and want all of the games, add this, if you're not so much into the nauticle, skip it.
Summary: First, all the 1-star reviews given are not a fair assessment of this new world itself. Just because people didn't read or understand that there was no actual DVD inside the case is no reason to give the actual product itself a 1 star.