Summary: They created a graphical masterpiece here... Unfortunately, they over simplified unit production.... everyone seems to have the same units and it cheapens the experience by making geography the only differentiating factor. It lacks the diversity, simplicity, and playability of medieval 2. It would be great, if not for having to be judged against the first shogun and medievals.
Summary: The basic total war style remains the same. The graphics and map change but the game experience is much the same. I'd like something that spanned Civilization (Big tech tree) + Total War (big complex battles) + Individual level Role Playing (Dragon Age or Mount and blade) allow jumping between levels. However this game is much like Total War - Empire, just in Japan.
Summary: The game is just too complex and for those who are not die hard Total War fans will have problems going through a long campaign mode. The in-game battles are fun and at times difficult but the challenging type of difficult. The economic part of the game is just downright frustrating and for me was the thing that killed the whole game for me. As a fan of Japanese history I was excited to play this game but I never was able to feel comfortable or excited about any clan.
Summary: Amazon's download speed is atrocious. I started my download a day ago and it still claims it will take somewhere from 12-16 hours more to download. I was getting consistent 11-12 mbps for the first couple hours, now I'm lucky to get 500 kbps. So many others have had this problem it needs to be addressed.
Summary: This addon to Total War: Shogun 2 is only moderatly successful. I had trouble getting into the game, whereas the original immediately captured me. For some reason, the dual clan leaders is distracting. I have played the original several times but could barely get through "Rise of the Samurai" once.
Summary: Shogun 2 is a great entry in the Total War franchise. Detailed reviews of the core game and Fall of the Samurai stand-alone expansion can be found on their respective Amazon pages and elsewhere. For those who are new to the game and wonder what this Gold Edition is missing, here is a list.
Summary: Will never do a download like this from amazon agen over 21 GBs. Took 3 days to download. Then you have to wate for anther day for steam to update. My download speed is 80-120 kbs. For a total download time of something like 4 days. :( The game is fun to play and I enjoyed the game but the download time was hard to take.
Summary: I love the game, the new characters are a lot of fun and I think it is a great continuation of the shogun series. The game still has a lot of bugs. You have a 1/3 chance that the entire map turns to ocean after a battle and you then have to save and reload the campaign to fix it. From what I read online this is happening to a lot of people. The load times are unbearable, to load the game takes up to 5 minutes!