www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Doom-3-pc.374503
7.3 out of 10

Doom 3

Great Deal: $11.99

Reviews and Problems with Doom 3

Showing 1-10 of 60
Overall 6
6.0

Good but not great

Sean, Amazon
4 March 2006
  • Summary: To make my review hopefully useful to you, I'll keep it short and to the point. Like many others I have followed the Wolfenstein and Doom progression over the years and I too got caught up in the hype surrounding this game. For me, any PFS is about 3 things; graphics, sound and gameplay. Yes, the graphics are very detailed and life like, but the levels all look very similar and after a while I wished they'd added some variety.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Third Time's the Curse

Brian M. Ranzoni "Da Killa B", Amazon
4 March 2006
  • Summary: 12 years after wincing my way through the originals, I picked up id Software's latest from my local Fred Meyers last Tuesday. By Saturday morning I watched the end credits scroll past my traumatized eyes. Clearly, id went old-school gameplay with the latest graphics in *Doom 3*. *D3* plays like *Quake*. It's dark and alien looking. Doors open automatically or you use the fire key to activate buttons. You have no alt-fire, stealth, lean, or use functions.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Awesome, to a point, then downhill. Too Bad really....

Nanohead "nanohead", Amazon
28 September 2005
  • Summary: Lots of people have covered this here, so I'll only summarize. This is a great game, for the first few hours. Then, you want to hang it up. Me, I was fine until I got to hell. Then, I wanted to simply quit, as it was impossible to proceed, and so dark, I couldnt tell what was going on. I've played dozens of FPS type games, and this was the first one that I started to hate halfway through.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Something went wrong...

Matthieu P. Raillard, Amazon
31 January 2005
  • Summary: During the development of Doom 3. What could have been one of the most amazing, atmospheric games became instead an amazing graphical tour-de-force marred by repetitive gameplay. The GOOD: Graphics are top notch, the sound is terrific and scary as anything, and the general mechanics of the game (move, shoot, etc) are well done. The idea for the story is also fun and creepy, and this game is quite atmospheric and effective in its scare tactics.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Good engine, tired premise

Big Joe '83, Amazon
20 September 2004
  • Summary: Co-founder of Id Software and technical director of DOOM3, John Carmack, is famous for once saying to Commander Keen creator, Tom Hall, during the development of the first DOOM ", Story in a game is like story in a porno. It's not important but it's expected to be there." A quote which pretty much explains Id Software's output since the departure of that other co-founder, John Romero.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Disappointing

RWB, Amazon
1 September 2004
  • Summary: Doom 3 was one of the most hyped games ever, and with good reason. It was a successor to the previous Dooms and with a major upgrade, especially in the graphics. Needless to say, I couldn't wait to play it. I was, however, sorely disappointed. Pros 1. Probably the best graphics in a videogame ever. 2. Some pretty cool environmennts. 3. Can scare the hell out of you. 4. Easy to pick up and play. True to the original. Cons 1. Very, VERY dark.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

could be better no brainer

S. HONG "bookmant", Amazon
15 August 2004
  • Summary: i am sure most would agree that the doom series (previous incarnations as Doom and Doom II) were pretty good FPS (first person shooter) games. but, Doom 3 (D3), a remake of Doom/DoomII, does not measure up to the other FPSs already in the FPS market, specifically "Far Cry", "Call of Duty" and even the older "Half-Life". measure up in terms of gameplay, interactivity and immersion. it is difficult to define what "gameplay" is because it is subjective.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Stellar graphics, mediocre gameplay

Rockin in the free world, Amazon
7 August 2004
  • Summary: As anyone interested in this game already knows, the graphics are fantastic. The environments are dark and scary and the sound is great. In my opinion that's all this game has to offer. The gameplay leaves much to be desired. Basically, you're just navigating dark rooms and corridors while being ambushed, over and over. It's a cheap trick and it gets old really fast.
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

Looks like a dream, plays like a nightmare

M. R Wilkes, Amazon
7 August 2004
  • Summary: I can only imagine the meeting that dreamed this game up: John Carmack: "OK everyone, we've decided on the final specs for Doom 3." Everyone Else: "Great!" JC: "We've decided it's only gonna be playable on Win2000/XP!" EE: "Fantastic!" JC: "And we're going to claim you can play it with only 384 megs of RAM and a 64-meg graphics card, even though it slows down a 3GHz P4 with a gig of RAM and a 256-meg card!" EE: "Cool!
  • Read full review
Overall 6
6.0

They missed the mark I'm afraid

A Reader, Amazon
6 August 2004
  • Summary: First let me say I have only played through the first few missions of the game. I don't think things change much going forward though from what others have written. ## Hardware: I have an Alienware P4 3.2Ghz PC with the nVidia GeForce FX 5950 Ultra video card. The game runs fine at 1024x768 and high detail (Ultra is the best). There is some slight texture draw but not bad.
  • Read full review
Next page >>