Reviews and Problems with Nikon 28-200mm f/3.5-5.6G ED-IF AF
Showing 1-10 of 12
Nikkor 28-200mm AF G Lens
Paul Garland, Amazon
3 April 2011
Summary: Nikon has discontinued this lens, which is a shame. It is lightweight, sharp, and makes a perfect walk around lens for any full frame (FX) Nikon DSLR like the D700. I bought mine used, for more money that it originally sold for new. Ken Rockwell gives this lens very high marks. For DX Nikon DSLRs there are many versatile and sharp zoom lenses, so I doubt that many DX shooters will buy this lens.
Summary: If you are like me, you really can't afford the 18-200MM VR Lens. Besides, the VR lens is sold out everywhere at this time. This 28-200 lens is really spectacular. Forget about people talking about barrel distortion, keystoning, etc. The images really speak for themselves. The human eye can accomodate small optical errors. Besides, who cares? The images from this lens are simply astounding. The lens is lightweight, very compact, sharp, and is an amazingly good value.
Summary: If you want to get an ultra zoom, which despite their problems in quality arr useful if you want to carry only one lens, most people's first choice is the Nikon 18-200mm; if you can find one and afford it. The second is Tamron's 18-250mm lens. The last is one of the 28-200mm (Don't touch the 28-300mm lenses) like these. This Nikon is by far the best. The reason why they're 28-200mm is because they were intended for film; where 28mm was a wide angle.
Summary: This lens gets along very well with my N75. I wanted a versatile lens that could go from wide-angle to telephoto, and that is exactly what this lens does. It is also extremely lightweight, extremely sturdy, and produces that classic Nikon background blur. (A pro or a con, depending on what you like.) The macro shots I've taken haven't disappointed me at all, they look very sharp to me---but I am a pretty casual photographer, and haven't played with many Nikon lenses.
Summary: After I bought the D50--my first DSLR--I went on the hunt for a good all-around lens. I was upgrading from a fixed lens system with 10X optical zoom, so I would settle for nothing less than a lens with 10X zoom equivalent. Luckily, with the D50 having a 1.5x crop factor, a 200mm lens would fit the bill fine. I found this lens on Amazon, and things fell into place.
Summary: This is an excellent general purpose lens. This lens is always on my D80 camera. Whether I want to shoot group of people close up or pull in a shoot from farther away, this lens will do it all. For longer shots I use a 70 - 300mm on special occasion, but normally I use the 28 - 200mm.
Summary: I read about this lens in the Nikon D7100 guide by well respected No.1 Camera guide author David Busch. He described it as one of the best lenses he had ever bought. Ken Rockwell also sings it's praises but says it is superseded by Nikon 18-200mm VR. I like what ken has to say on a lot of things, but David says he wouldn't part with his for the newer lens. Apparently only 60'000 of these were made, and finding one in mint condition can be a struggle.
Summary: There are even more reasons to keep dust out of a digital camera than a regular film camera, so if you can find one lens that will do ninety percent of everything it's a real bonus: your SLR becomes a sealed box that you almost never open to the elements. I use this lens on my Nikon D70 (where it's the equivalent of about 40 - 300mm) and have very rarely wanted to swap it for a wider or longer lens.