Summary: The only reason I haven't returned it was because a cheap old IDE drive is fairly hard to come by and it had low wear on it. I got an old HP Pavilion DV4000 laptop for free that I converted into a Smoothwall that needed a new drive and this fit the bill.
Pros: This one works and was available.
Cons: Buyer beware! Looking at the drive it was evident that this drive was being sold as new but was previously used/active for over 8000 hours (2 years) based on the the drives SMART logging and firmware. This drive is way over priced for an old piece of used hardware.