Summary: It is the company that sells these, Dulcet, that impressed me most. They helped me get the right one when I ordered wrong. Great company to do business with. The drive is fine. Toshiba makes a good one. Still going strong. No Problems. Just make sure whether you need the ribbon drive or pin drive.
Summary: The product was relatively cheap and I was pleased that it was sent in an adequate packaging, I was mostly afraid that it could have been damaged during the mailing process. There were absolutely no problems during the installation and my 4th Gen. iPod Classic is working once more with a little extra capacity.
Summary: I used this drive to replace a dead drive in an iPod 3G I refurbished for RetroSonicFidelity. I really like this drive in the iPod because of the weight it gives to the iPod. Although flash storage will last longer and draw less power from the battery, I still really like the weight this gives the iPod over the power benefits of flash storage.
Summary: My current harddrive luckily didn't die completely, but all of a sudden slowed down to a crawl (20 minute boot up and you could hear it clicking). Lasted a solid 5 years. It took some searching to find a replacement (that didn't cost a fortune), and I found this one (with help from the other review saying it worked for the Dell Latitude X1). Purchased it from the Amazon seller Santechusa, and it arrive in 1.5 days :) New harddrive is humming along nicely. ps.