Summary: My late 2008 MacBook Pro 3.1 needed a larger hard drive. My first choice was a 500 GB WD Scorpion Blue HD which was highly rated in general, but as I found out later, did not work well with the proprietary Apple disc controller software on this laptop version. I had to return the WD drive because it would endlessly spool up and down and go through enormous numbers of disc cycling even when the laptop was idle.
Summary: Im using this in my ps3 right now and when it gets under high effort this thing sounds like my printer! but other than that, it does what its supposed to do which is back up my damn files. Would I go with something else? ehhh probably, it only gets loud when its under stress, so yeah, if noise is a factor for you, go ahead but if u could care less, this is a go! edit; after using this a bit more.
Summary: I bought this as a cheap replacement for a laptop hard drive that was playing up after a minor accident! Fortunately that drive was still accessible for file recovery on removal although it wouldn't boot the laptop. I recovered all the essential stuff and had a mirror image on another drive that was only a few weeks old. This unit was delivered promptly and was easy to install using the old carriage.
Summary: this is a very fast drive in the right medium. in a usb3 icybox dock i was able to write to it at 65MB/s. and copy from it at 80MB/s. in a orico usb3 2588 portable caddy speeds were 30MB/s. the drive is also very thin if that is a requirement you have.