Summary: Sega’s monster-editor-slash-Olympics-game may appeal to kids and even older gamers who like to get creative.
Pros: Contains the best console creativity tool since Mario Paint, Outrageous accessories and lots of ‘em, Sharp, colorful graphics (the kind GameCube excels at)
Cons: Heavy linkage between monster creation and mini-game completion, Some poor mini-game designs, Worthless multiplayer feature
Summary: Amazing Island is decent entertainment for a younger crowd, though they'd probably prefer a game featuring one of the franchises it tries so hard to emulate.