Summary: It is very light, hopefully durability will not be an issue. I will be buying a second controller.
Pros: Fits perfectly in your hand and is comfortable when using for several hours. Brings back great memories of past gaming experiences. A must have for first person shooters and any Virtual Console games you download. The joysticks feel very responsive and firm, so I think it will hold up well to vigorous use.
Cons: The black finish shows fingerprints all over, so don't expect it to look clean even after one use.
Summary: I didn't realize it was an attachment to the bottom of a Wiimote and not a separate controller. Had I realized that, I would have gotten one a second Wiimote instead, as there aren't as many games to use the classic controller as I had first hoped.
Pros: Let's me play all me old SNES games, and certain Wii games with no problem. I like the black, too.
Cons: Left joystick seems to get stuck near the bottom from time to time. This makes everything continue moving downwards. It comes and goes though. This would be why it gets 4 eggs instead of 5.