Conclusion: At 16.7 cubic feet, the Kenmore Elite 28712 upright freezer isn't as large as the top-rated Frigidaire FFU21F5HW (Est. $600) , but users say it's very easy to organize. It's also packed with features, from adjustable door storage to a soft-freeze zone for ice cream. Its temperature performance is good, but its efficiency is only so-so despite its Energy Star rating. Users also have some complaints about its noise level and reliability.
Pros: Good performance, Easy to organize, Luxury features
Cons: Somewhat noisy, So-so efficiency, Some reliability problems