www.testfreaks.com

Reviews, reviews, reviews...

Guerlain-shalimar-edp.33550473
9.7 out of 10

Guerlain Shalimar

Best Price at Amazon

Reviews and Problems with Guerlain Shalimar

Showing 1-10 of 19
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

paisleypunk, makeupalley.com
5 August 2014
  • Summary: I love vanilla, and was excited to try this after reading all the fuss about what a classic it is. But honestly... ugh! How does anyone smell vanilla in this? To me it smells exactly like baby powder... but ten times as potent. As a reviewer below noted, it does "settle down" after some time, but it's still way too strong (and I used only one spritz), and smells very little like how I expected it to. More old and powdery than gourmand and sexy.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

Matter of taste

Andreia Cruz, amazon.com
2 April 2014
  • Summary: Although I can clearly tell it is a high quality product, it is not for me. It smells like a mix of talc and wood and I found it to be more of a masculine, vintage scent. Since can not be returned I will gift it.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

McSwimmer, makeupalley.com
9 February 2014
  • Summary: After reading all the endearing positive reviews of Shalimar (here and at other websites), I just had to smell it for myself. I went to Macy's just to try it. It's very strong. Overpowering for sure! A bottle would last you a lifetime! It was rather annoying after I sprayed a tiny bit on. It settled down about 4 hours later and wasn't too bad. But who wants to wait that long to get an acceptable scent? Not I. I do not smell much vanilla in this fragrance.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

Not what it used to be.

Lorraine Schwartz, amazon.com
16 December 2013
  • Summary: I am not sure this isn't counterfeit. It is not the same color nor does it seem to smell exactly like my previous bottle. This does not have the intensity of the older one and yes, they are both Eau de Toilette spray. Additionally, the bottle is a bit awkward to hold and spray.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

Very disappointed with this product

Human-At-Large "anntootsie", amazon.com
27 July 2013
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

Kysyona, makeupalley.com
1 May 2013
  • Summary: I am rating the modern formulation here since I never manage to win an old sample on ebay ( but I live in hope! :) ) The bottle is prima, and what's in it started with a blast of musk ( read dust ) and settled into a stale vanilla mixed with soda baking powder. The End. If I get hold of a vintage I will update, but so far it's not worth the time I could take describing how disappointing that was.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

shalimar - It's not the same

neets, Saks Fifth Avenue
7 February 2012
  • Summary: I have used Shalimar for over 25 years. Have always loved it. The last few bottle I've bought...both Eau de Parfum and Eau de Toilette (purchased at Saks 5th Ave) no longer smell like Shalimar. When sprayed they have a harsh metalic smell. Shalimar has always faded to a warm, powdery, delicate scent. These do not. I thought it might be a change in my body chemistry or my sense of smell so I had friends spray it on themselves. They had the same reaction.
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

inglaterra, makeupalley.com
7 December 2011
  • Summary: This is for the edt version -- "the Batman bottle" :P The parfum is 100% purely sublime, nearly perfect in every way. Its euphoric and spellbinding in a way only Samsara has ever been, to my nose. That being said, the eau de toilette is vile, revolting and sad. It smells sickly to me. I can't believe I am smelling the same perfume family. I sprayed at waited for the Shalimar goodness to unfold, but it never does. Have I been spoiled by the parfum?
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

Tamahawk, makeupalley.com
21 July 2011
  • Summary: I wanted to love this so much... I love the history behind the perfume, but I just can't pull this off. I don't know if it's the jasmine or the incense, but it smells like sweaty, spit covered microphone (I am a singer lol) on me. I respect the scent of the microphone and the scent of Shalimar, but there is no way I want to smell like it on my person! Cheers to all of you that this smells better on...
  • Read full review
Overall 4
4.0

User Review

Arik26, makeupalley.com
19 January 2011
  • Summary: *Edit* Tried the eau de parfum yesterday and I must say, I like the deep, smoky, richness that it settles into, but I'm still catching whiffs of something acrid in it . Maybe it's the Iris. The main thing I dislike about this fragrance that I oddly never really noticed before is the strong bergamot top note. Never been a fan of bergamot, or any scent that has a lemony smell in general. And Shalimar's bergamot is too closely reminiscent of baby wipes for my comfort.
  • Read full review
Next page >>