Summary: I would give it 5 stars, but it's not quite as good as the Lego Star Wars saga game. Decent replay value. Has the same feel and ethos of other Lego video games. My 6yo loves it (but not as much as LOTR or Star Wars).
Summary: My two boys 10 an 13 love it. Of course they love all things Lego. We don't have other game systems so I don't know how it compares to other systems. Game has enough puzzles and excitement to keep them interested on and off for a year now.
Summary: This game is fun to play but has some issues. It freezes in a couple of spots if you play for an extended period of time (more than 45 min). Usually turning the console off and letting it sit for awhile solves the problem. This seems to be a problem for most of the people that bought this game. For me it will be a one time game. I will probably sell/trade it in after I'm through it. Maybe for a younger player it will be more entertaining.